Research Forum
Observations about "Ray Peat diet" followers, advocates of Poison/"Vitamin A"
Quote from Dr. Garrett Smith on November 14, 2018, 6:37 pmFrom someone quite familiar with Ray Peat diet forums on the internet:
The Ray Peat fans are so gung ho about vitamin A that when a dude gave himself hypervitaminosis A and D by using high dose supplements they still acted like it was no big deal!
There is a lady who after 5 months on the diet at the age of 52 developed type 1 diabetes. She now requires insulin the rest of her life. She thought it was the sugar. But I asked her did you greatly increase vitamin A? She said yes she had been using a supplement! Ugh!
I am pissed because I was duped by a few members who pushed vitamin A when getting a lot of UV. So I would supplement or eat liver whenever I got a lot of UV to 'balance the vitamin D'. There was a practitioner who also said using vitamin D protects you against vitamin A overload. Well tell that to the guy who wrecked himself supplementing very high doses of both!
My comments:
- Vitamin D supplements DO NOT counteract or "balance out" Poison/"Vitamin A" in the system. In fact, both compounds (Vitamin D is a family of hormones, Poison/"Vitamin A" is a toxin) act to raise calcium in the system, which is a cause of many of the health problems related to their intake.
- Studies connecting Poison/"Vitamin A" with hypercalcemia (high blood calcium, link must be opened on a computer, not a phone)
- Studies connecting Vitamin D supplements with hypercalcemia (high blood calcium, link must be opened on a computer, not a phone)
- There will be another thread on the ludicrous statement that somehow Vitamin D "protects" one against Vitamin A, or vice versa.
- Grant Genereux demonstrated the connection between Poison/"Vitamin A" toxicity and nearly all forms of autoimmunity in his free ebooks (linked on this blog-forum in another thread), so the Type 1 Diabetes connection is not a surprise.
From someone quite familiar with Ray Peat diet forums on the internet:
The Ray Peat fans are so gung ho about vitamin A that when a dude gave himself hypervitaminosis A and D by using high dose supplements they still acted like it was no big deal!
There is a lady who after 5 months on the diet at the age of 52 developed type 1 diabetes. She now requires insulin the rest of her life. She thought it was the sugar. But I asked her did you greatly increase vitamin A? She said yes she had been using a supplement! Ugh!
I am pissed because I was duped by a few members who pushed vitamin A when getting a lot of UV. So I would supplement or eat liver whenever I got a lot of UV to 'balance the vitamin D'. There was a practitioner who also said using vitamin D protects you against vitamin A overload. Well tell that to the guy who wrecked himself supplementing very high doses of both!
My comments:
- Vitamin D supplements DO NOT counteract or "balance out" Poison/"Vitamin A" in the system. In fact, both compounds (Vitamin D is a family of hormones, Poison/"Vitamin A" is a toxin) act to raise calcium in the system, which is a cause of many of the health problems related to their intake.
- Studies connecting Poison/"Vitamin A" with hypercalcemia (high blood calcium, link must be opened on a computer, not a phone)
- Studies connecting Vitamin D supplements with hypercalcemia (high blood calcium, link must be opened on a computer, not a phone)
- There will be another thread on the ludicrous statement that somehow Vitamin D "protects" one against Vitamin A, or vice versa.
- Grant Genereux demonstrated the connection between Poison/"Vitamin A" toxicity and nearly all forms of autoimmunity in his free ebooks (linked on this blog-forum in another thread), so the Type 1 Diabetes connection is not a surprise.
Licensed Naturopathic Physician (NMD) in Arizona
NutritionDetective.com, home of the Love Your Liver program
YouTube - FaceBook - Instagram - Twitter